What It Really Means To Be An Introvert, According To Neuroscience

Disclosure: this page may contain affiliate links to select partners. We receive a commission should you choose to make a purchase after clicking on them. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Are You Really An Introvert?

A woman sits cross-legged on a couch, wearing a cozy sweater, and reads a book with a smile. A wooden tray with a mug and an open book is beside her. The setting appears relaxed and comfortable.

You probably hear the word bandied about all the time, and you may even identify as one yourself, but what is an introvert, exactly?

How do you define an introvert? What does being introverted actually mean in day-to-day life?

The answers to these questions are not as straightforward as you may think because the common usage of the term is not as precise as it should be.

People talk about themselves or others as being introverts when they are actually referring to personality traits that have nothing to do with introversion.

To be sure that you are an introvert, you first have to understand what being one actually means.

While a simple, singular definition is hard to pin down, we can discuss the differences between introverts and extroverts and examine some of the characteristics often considered to belong to introverted people.

So let’s try and finally tackle that all-important question: ‘Am I an introvert?’

The Answer Lies In Your Brain

A bearded man with glasses, wearing a light blue shirt, smiles while seated in front of a bookshelf filled with books and boxes. The background features a variety of colorful files and office supplies.

Being an introvert (or an extrovert for that matter) is actually all about how your brain rewards you for different activities.

It turns out that each personality type has distinct structures and activity levels in their brains, and these influence their behaviors and how they feel.

Let’s look at 6 ways the brain influences where you are on the introversion-extroversion scale.

1. The role of dopamine sensitivity.

A person with curly hair and glasses is holding a yellow mug close to their mouth. They are wearing a pink top and a gray wrap, and they are outdoors with a blurred background of greenery. They appear to be enjoying a beverage.

This neurotransmitter has multiple effects when produced in the brain, but the one we are going to focus on is how it acts as a reward.

Dopamine is released when we engage in an exciting external activity – eating a favorite food, going to a gig, meeting with friends – but the tolerance for it varies significantly between introverts and extroverts.

Extroverts simply can’t get enough of the stuff.

Their brains light up and they are filled with a euphoric happiness as a reward for doing something that arouses the mind.

They are hugely tolerant of dopamine and can easily cope with a stream of it being released.

Introverts, on the other hand, are far more sensitive to dopamine.

They will often experience the same initial buzz from it, but soon become overstimulated and weary.

This is why prolonged social interaction is so draining for introverts; their brains release more and more dopamine and it can interfere with their normal cognitive functioning.

The initial reward soon turns into a punishment, but the mechanism by which dopamine is released simply can’t tell when this tipping point occurs.

It continues to pump it out even when an introvert has entered a serious come down phase.

That’s why an introvert might really enjoy the first 30 minutes of a party before suddenly feeling an irresistible urge to run for the nearest exit.

If we were to picture an imaginary bar where they served dopamine instead of alcohol, introverts would be the lightweights whose heads feel fuzzy after just one drink, whereas extroverts can happily keep chugging away until kicking out time.

2. Acetylcholine is also involved in reward.

A person stands in a forest, eyes closed, with a peaceful expression. They are wearing a warm, light-colored jacket and a dark beanie with a checkered pattern. Sunlight filters through the trees in the background.

Dopamine isn’t the only chemical messenger in the brain that rewards us for certain behaviors.

There is another one that plays a big role in the separation of introverts and extroverts.

Acetylcholine gives us a smooth, calming type of happiness when we indulge in a little introspection.

When our thoughts turn inward, when we shut off the noise of the outside world, this clever little neurotransmitter puts a smile on our faces and a warm glow in our hearts.

Oh, but it only works for introverts.

Yeah, that’s right; it’s their very own magic elixir.

You see, while it is present in the brains of extroverts, they have very little in the way of a reaction to it.

Because they do not receive any reward when it is released, extroverts aren’t drawn to the quiet, self-reflective kinds of pastimes that introverts love.

For introverts, however, this more mellow and gentle high is precisely what they like.

There is far less risk of overstimulation with acetylcholine than there is with dopamine.

Thus, the lure of a good book, cozy night in, or deep one-on-one conversation is too much to resist.

3. The brain’s baseline level of arousal plays a role.

An elderly woman with gray hair tied back is wearing round glasses and a light beige sweater. She is smiling and looking to the side in a cozy room with a shelf and soft lighting in the background.

It has also been shown that the brains of introverts have a higher baseline level of arousal (activity in the brain) compared to extroverts.

In essence, they are doing more work in the background; more thinking, planning, and analyzing.

Why does this matter?

Well, due to these already elevated levels of arousal, introverts have a lower capacity for additional stimulation.

They have too much going on in their minds already, and adding further things to process only pushes them closer to their comfortable limit.

4. Thickness of gray matter has an impact.

A man wearing glasses and a beige sweater is sitting at a table, holding a pencil and working on a crossword puzzle in a newspaper. A cup of coffee is partially visible on the table in the background.

Another way in which the brain of an introvert is different from that of an extrovert is in the thickness of the gray matter in certain regions of the prefrontal cortex.

This part of the brain is typically associated with abstract thought and decision-making.

This could be a result of the introvert’s fondness for extended periods of contemplation and deliberation.

It may also hold the key to their general slowness in making decisions.

5. The brain responds differently to people.

Two women hugging indoors. One facing the camera looks upset while the other has her back to the camera. The background features a brick wall, creating a cozy atmosphere.

Researchers found that, when shown pictures of human faces and flowers, the response from introverts was no different.

Extroverts, on the other hand, displayed a higher response to the faces.

This suggests that, to an introvert, a human is no more intrinsically interesting than a flower or other object.

This once again demonstrates how the brains of these opposing personality types differ from one another and why introverts are less keen on social gatherings.

6. The reward of social interaction.

Two women are sitting at an outdoor table, each holding a takeaway coffee cup. They are engaged in conversation, with one gesturing as she speaks. The background is softly blurred, suggesting a casual, relaxed setting.

After you consider the points above, you can draw one striking conclusion about why introverts and extroverts behave in different ways.

Much of the time, our actions are driven by a reward, whether that is instant or delayed, and it is this method of reward that separates these personality traits.

Introverts find little reward in prolonged social interaction and, in fact, experience the very opposite of a reward the longer this exposure continues.

Extroverts, however, receive a large reward for social interaction.

Introverts find low-intensity activities which usually involve very few people – maybe just themselves – to be far more rewarding.

Extroverts get almost no such reward from these activities.

About The Author

Steve Phillips-Waller is the founder and editor of A Conscious Rethink. He has written extensively on the topics of life, relationships, and mental health for more than 8 years.