The past holds an allure for many. It may contain positive memories that we want to relive or negative memories that we wish we could change. It’s easy to get wrapped up in the memories of good times when things aren’t going so well in the present. On the other hand, the bad memories stick with us, too. Bad memories may be intrusive, like trauma or making a mistake that you wish you could change.
Still, you can’t live in the past, whether good or bad. And if you find that you can’t stop thinking about the past, here are some reasons why.
1. You’re stuck in a rumination cycle.
Rumination is a cognitive process characterized by repetitive and obsessive thinking about negative experiences or emotions. That is, one does not just think about a past event and then let it go. Instead, they think about the event, what they could have done differently, or struggle to find a “why” over and over. You may find yourself trying to stop cringing at your past, but can’t because it loops over and over in your mind.
The emotional problems that rumination causes are varied, and according to Psych Central, it makes it harder for you to find a solution or closure. Instead of focusing on how to fix the issue, you focus on the issue itself. But you won’t find a solution within the issue. Instead, you have to look outside and around the issue for a solution.
Rumination encourages maladaptive thoughts and behavior. You may become more prone to looking at a similar present situation through an interpretation of the past event. By doing that, you can easily mess up your present. For example, if you were cheated on in a past relationship, you may fall into the pattern of assuming your new partner is going to be dishonest. That can quickly destroy a relationship.
2. You’ve got unresolved trauma.
Trauma is a significant event (or prolonged series of events) that leaves a lasting psychological impact. The effects of unresolved trauma do affect the present. Traumatic experiences are often responsible for things like intrusive thoughts, hyperarousal, avoidance behavior, and emotional dysregulation. According to Psychology Today, this is because traumatic events activate the part of our brain (the amygdala) that is responsible for handling threats.
Hyperarousal is a state characterized by hypervigilance and increased startle responses. A heightened state of arousal makes it difficult for a person to relax enough to enjoy the present because they are constantly waiting for the next traumatic event. Furthermore, hyperarousal tends to redirect one’s thoughts and emotions back to the past event.
Emotional dysregulation causes a person to be unable to presently manage their emotions, leading to intense and unpredictable emotional responses. As a result, the person struggles to disengage from the past because they are still trying to process the emotions and events of their traumatic experience.
Avoidance behavior causes the trauma survivor to avoid emotions and circumstances that touch on their traumatic experience(s), which prevents them from addressing it. This, in turn, causes them to constantly circle back to their trauma because they aren’t resolving it.
3. You’re prone to negative bias.
People tend to focus more on past negative events than positive ones. That focus regularly draws your attention back to the past. The more you think about the negativity of the past, the more your brain fixates on the emotions and circumstances surrounding it. That causes you to constantly look back to try to interpret those circumstances and emotions. Furthermore, it causes your neutral and positive experiences to fade into the background.
According to Very Well Mind, confirmation bias causes an individual to seek out information or interpret information that confirms their negative beliefs or expectations about themselves, others, or the world. If you look for confirmation, you’ll always find it, because your brain wants to interpret new information negatively when you succumb to cognitive bias.
That reinforces the cycle of rumination and preoccupation with the past.
4. You fear the unknown.
A fear of the unknown significantly contributes to dwelling in the past. The past is known and familiar. It offers a safety blanket that a future unknown just doesn’t. The future offers anxiety and apprehension about what may or may not come. Faced with the uncertainty of the future, an individual may instead retreat into the past where they feel more control and less vulnerable.
People often fear losing their sense of self too. A person’s sense of self is mostly forged in the past. Granted, you are still creating your sense of self right now, but it’s hard to tell because you’re currently having the experience. Sometimes people get stuck in the past because they’re so afraid of losing their self-identity in the present and future.
What-if scenarios keep an individual in the past because they may constantly wonder what would have happened had they made that different decision. How much better would their life have been if they had just taken that chance? What if?
5. You’re experiencing guilt and regret.
A person may get stuck in past thoughts because they did something they regret. They spend their time preoccupied with the hurt and harm that they caused. They continuously reexamine the situation they regret and feel guilty for, and won’t allow themselves to heal and move on from it. Furthermore, they may be consciously or subconsciously punishing themselves for the bad choice even if it was completely out of their hands.
Emotional distress and guilt are common with regret. A regretful circumstance is never a good one. The more you dwell on it, the more negative feelings and guilt it creates. This causes you to focus more on the guilt and regret, which creates more negative feelings, and then it just perpetuates that negative cycle.
And since guilt forces a person to continue to look back on a situation, it reinforces the regret that a person feeling guilt experiences.
6. You have attachment issues.
Attachment issues shape your relationship with memories and past experiences. A person with attachment issues may develop a strong emotional dependency on past relationships or experiences, particularly if those relationships provided a sense of security or validation. The loss of these attachments can cause feelings of emptiness and longing, causing an individual to dwell on the past.
A person may find themselves idealizing past relationships due to attachment issues. Their brain automatically focuses their thoughts on the few good qualities of a relationship while dismissing or minimizing the rest. This is one reason that some people miss an abusive partner even though they understand how bad the experience was for them.
A reluctance to let go of the past may be a person’s way of avoiding dealing with it by confronting it in the present. The more they focus on the past, the less time they need to think about the present and how to heal the wounds that their past may have caused.
7. You’re caught up in nostalgia.
Nostalgia, or a sentimental longing for the past, can contribute to an individual getting stuck in their past. Nostalgia offers comfort and security that the present may not. It’s a fondness for days gone by that either are or are perceived as easier. But perception matters, because those days gone by may not have been better at all. Instead, you may find yourself just focused on the few positive things and dismissing all of the negative.
Nostalgia provides a sense of continuity. That is, it’s easier to link your present with an identifiable past than it is to face the uncertainty of your present and future. After all, you never know what will happen tomorrow. But, if you reminisce and dwell in the past, you don’t have to be afraid of the future because you’re tricking yourself into thinking that your present is still directly connected to the past, even if it’s not.
Loss and change are difficult. They can be so painful at times. Nostalgia may be a coping mechanism that distracts one from their loss or negative changes in their life.
8. You’ve experienced loss and grief.
The loss of a loved one or significant life change can trigger a lasting grieving process which causes a person to dwell on the past. It may be that the past was genuinely better. It could also be that cognitive biases are at work, causing the person to remember a situation more positively than it was.
Loss is always difficult. One day everything is good, the next day there is a gaping hole in you that was once filled by something you had. Maybe it was a person, a career, a beloved pet, or anything you feel strongly about. That’s hard to handle. Whatever it is, you may struggle to forget bad memories. Some people try to handle it for years and still don’t make much progress because they’ve been traumatized, and need care related to resolving trauma.
9. You base your sense of identity on past experiences.
Many people derive their sense of identity from past experiences. They may not be able to do the same things that they once did, so they cling to the past because it helps them cope with the present. For example, let’s say you traveled a lot when you were younger. You viewed yourself as a carefree spirit always ready for the next adventure.
But what happens if life slows down? If more responsibilities start cropping up? What if you settle down and have a family? You can’t just be a carefree spirit and pack up for a trip. What if you can’t afford to travel? You may still cling to that previous identity where you were a free spirit and traveler doing free spirit things.
That doesn’t mean you’re not still those things. Maybe when circumstances change you’ll be a free spirit and traveler once again. But, for now, memories have to suffice.
10. You’re lacking closure.
A lack of closure creates a sense of helplessness, unresolved tension, and incompleteness. When past events lack closure, individuals may feel as though they have unfinished business that needs to be resolved. This sense of unfinished business can cause rumination as the person regularly thinks about what they should have done differently and how they can get closure now.
The absence of closure may also cause intrusive thoughts as memories keep resurfacing. Intrusive thoughts may take the form of unanswered questions, unresolved emotions, or lingering doubts, making it difficult to control your thoughts and move on. It may also spur on negative emotions like anger, regret, and sadness.
Closure often plays a role in self-identity, particularly when a past circumstance is part of your present identity. The person may find themselves uncertain of who they are today or be unsure of their own actions and motivations in the past, even if they would be clear to a neutral third party.
——
There’s nothing wrong with thinking about the past in small doses. It becomes an issue when it starts affecting your present life in such a way that it decreases your quality of life. Sure, you can feel sad because of an opportunity you missed years ago. However, it should be fleeting. It’s not something you should be thinking about day after day to the point you can’t enjoy the present at all.
If you find yourself dwelling on the past so much it affects your present, it would be a good idea to speak to a therapist about it.
