Talk to an expert from Relationship Hero for personalized relationship advice

12 Chilling Signs Someone You Trust Is A Wolf In Sheep’s Clothing

Disclosure: this page may contain affiliate links to select partners. We receive a commission should you choose to make a purchase after clicking on them. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Watch out for these 12 behaviors.

A woman with short brown hair in a denim jacket playfully holds her hand to her lips, looking sideways with a mischievous expression. The background is a bright yellow.
©Image license via Depositphotos

There are few feelings as terrible as the sudden sinking feeling you get when you realize you’ve trusted the wrong person. It’s especially bad if you’ve trusted this person for years, and only now discover that they’ve had ulterior motives the entire time.

Keep an eye out for these telltale signs, as they may indicate that someone close to you isn’t the trustworthy confidante you thought they were.

1. People around you suddenly know things you shared in confidence.

Two women are sitting close together. One woman in a striped shirt is holding a cup, while the other whispers into her ear. The scene appears intimate, with the whispering woman leaning in slightly.
©Image license via Depositphotos

It’s very strange when people around you ask for details about a subject that you only ever discussed with one person. You may have trusted this person to keep this secret, but all of a sudden this information seems to be common knowledge.

Few things hurt as badly as being stabbed in the back by someone you actually allowed to get close to you, especially if you’ve kept most people at a distance due to past betrayals but finally decided to let someone “in”.

2. When they laugh or smile, it never reaches their eyes.

A young woman with long brown hair and wearing a blue sweater is smiling while listening attentively to an unseen person gesturing in the foreground. They are outdoors, with a calm, sunlit setting and buildings in the background.
©Image license via Depositphotos

A sincere smile will engage the small muscles around the eyes, while a fake smile will simply engage the mouth and cheeks. Watch people carefully when they laugh or smile in your company, as their microexpressions will shed light on their true intentions.

According to research, children as young as four or five can tell a fake smile from a real one, and will intuit that those who are faking their smiles will be less likely to be nice to them.

3. This person derives a bit too much amusement from your pain.

A man in a white shirt stands against a red background, laughing with eyes closed. He points towards the camera with one hand, while the other rests on his stomach.
©Image license via Depositphotos

Maybe they’re a bit too rough when they fight with you and call you a baby when you complain that they’ve hurt you. Alternatively, they may tickle you and don’t stop when you ask them to — instead, they laugh and continue doing so anyway.

This type of behavior indicates a rather strong sadistic streak, which is more common than you might imagine. Research shared on Psychology Today indicates that a startling number of people are everyday sadists, and those around them rarely have any idea.

4. They utilize intoxicants to achieve an aim with you.

Two men are seated at a bar, raising their beer glasses toward each other in a toast. One is wearing a white shirt, and the other has a checkered shirt. The bar counter has a white, hexagonal tile design while sunlight filters through the windows in the background.
©Image license via Depositphotos

Does this person often encourage you to drink with them until you pass out? Or have you found yourself spilling your guts to them while under the influence of some type of intoxicant? If so, then they may have been plying you for information when you’ve been in a vulnerable, suggestible state.

 

During these blackout periods (which you likely don’t remember), you may have divulged personal secrets or details, ranging from marital infidelity to the passwords to your various devices.

5. What they say to you and how they behave are two different things.

A woman with glasses stands holding a coffee cup and books, looking down at a large coffee stain on her shirt. Two people in the background, a man and a woman, are pointing at her and laughing. They are outside next to a large building with trees nearby.
©Image license via Depositphotos

Actions speak louder than words. If this person’s actions don’t match the things they’ve said to you, be on your guard immediately.

For example, has this person said they’ve always got your back, but then they join in with others when they’re making fun of you? Or have they said they’ll be there for you any time you need their help, but they always seem to have something else that’s more important going on when you do ask them for assistance? These are clear red flags.

6. They’re “boiling the frog.”

A person hands a credit card to another person's outstretched hand, holding a receipt or bill folder. A third person in a red dress is visible in the background, sitting at a dining table with a plate of food and a glass of wine.
©Image license via Depositphotos

A frog put into tepid water which is very gradually increased to boiling won’t realize the danger it’s in until it’s too late. This is much like a wolf in sheep’s clothing who gradually makes harmful changes to your relationship that go unnoticed by you because they are so slow and subtle.

Although things between you may have been equal at the beginning, you may discover that they’ve been taking advantage of you more regularly. For example, in the past, they may have let you buy lunch or pay for parking occasionally, but now they seem to expect you to do so.

Similarly, they may be overstepping when it comes to your home or workplace. They may show up uninvited and expect to be catered to, or help themselves to things in your kitchen without even asking.

7. They’re getting increasingly more controlling.

A woman with brown hair and a striped sweater is leaning towards a man with dark hair and a blue sweater. They are sitting by a window, facing each other and talking animatedly. The background shows a blurred view of trees and buildings outside.
©Image license via Depositphotos

This is often the case with someone who mistakes kindness and generosity for weakness and subservience. Over time their behavior tends to get more obvious and out in the open as they grow more comfortable with being controlling and doling out orders.

They don’t like to be challenged and may act as though they’re hurt or offended if you call them out on their dominating behavior — gaslighting you into believing that you’ve taken things the wrong way, and that they would never behave in such a manner.

8. They display a sudden personality shift once they’ve achieved a goal.

A woman stands with her hand on her forehead, appearing stressed or upset, while a man sitting on a couch behind her is gesturing and talking as if arguing or explaining something. They are in a modern kitchen and living area.
©Image license via Depositphotos

Many people will create a snare of their own personality to attain a long-term goal. They’ll do their research to find out everything a person likes and then cultivate a personality that melds seamlessly with it. If a romantic relationship is the aim, the target may fall head over heels in love with the one they think is their ideal soulmate when in reality they are far, far from it.

Once the paperwork is signed, however, the carefully constructed facade drops. They’ve gotten what they wanted, and will only benefit from the situation from here on in.

9. When you meet other people who know them, they seem to describe a completely different person.

Two women are sitting at an outdoor café. One woman, facing the camera, has long brown hair, looks surprised, and has her hand over her mouth. The other woman, with her back to the camera, is wearing a green top. Both have drinks in front of them.
©Image license via Depositphotos

Let’s say you meet a random stranger and it comes up in conversation that they know the person in question. They might share details with you that you’d never heard before, or that completely contradict what this person has shared with you in the past.

Furthermore, the details they share might paint a completely different picture of the person you thought you knew: you may discover that they served time, or that they have kids in another city that they never told you about.

10. You’ve witnessed their mask drop in crisis situations.

Two people are sitting at a table, each holding a glass of beer, engaged in conversation. One person has gray hair and glasses, wearing a navy sweater, and the other person has short hair, wearing a green shirt. Shelves and decor fill the background.
©Image license via Depositphotos

One blessing that often occurs in the midst of disaster is that you see your acquaintances in a clearer light. Someone you haven’t had a great relationship with may step up and work tirelessly beside you to help out, while the wolf in sheep’s clothing will abandon you for a more comfortable situation.

Those with bad intent may also let their masks fall if they are very tired or inebriated. They may joke about hurting you in some way, or tell you how they really feel about you.

11. Topics they return to involve probing you for sensitive or financial information.

Two women are sitting at a white kitchen table having a conversation. One woman holds a mug, and there are cupcakes and tea on the table. The kitchen in the background is bright and modern.
©Image license via Depositphotos

Always pay attention to what topics people keep trying to return to during conversations. For example, when you spend time with your friends, do you discuss everything under the sun? Or do some of them keep trying to prod you for information?

Some may seek to know these details just in case of an emergency so they’ll be able to retrieve your money or documents if you’re incapacitated, or if your house is burning down. You know, to “help” you.

12. They make “jokes” about blackmailing you with deeply personal information you’ve shared with them.

Two women are having an animated conversation outside a modern glass building. The woman on the left gestures expressively with a smile, while the woman on the right listens attentively, her back facing the camera.
©Image license via Depositphotos

Few things can make your guts fall into your shoes like realizing you’ve shared some seriously sensitive information with a person who might use it to screw you over. They may have worked diligently to gain your trust over a long period of time, and you thought they had proven themselves loyal to you, but then they make a “joke” about something like this.

If this happens, change your passwords and come clean about whatever info they have so there’s no leverage over you. Don’t wait, things will only get worse with time.

About The Author

Finn Robinson has spent the past few decades travelling the globe and honing his skills in bodywork, holistic health, and environmental stewardship. In his role as a personal trainer and fitness coach, he’s acted as an informal counselor to clients and friends alike, drawing upon his own life experience as well as his studies in both Eastern and Western philosophies. For him, every day is an opportunity to be of service to others in the hope of sowing seeds for a better world.